Showing posts with label Africa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Africa. Show all posts

Monday, June 30, 2008

Desmond Tutu, Neocon

It took a few years, but Archbishop Desmond Tutu is finally coming around to the idea of using military force to topple dictators and liberate their subjects.

In an interview with the BBC, Archbishop Tutu urged the international community to intervene in Zimbabwe, and said he would support the deployment of a UN force to restore order in the country.

Speaking on the BBC’s Andrew Marr programme, the former anti-apartheid leader said: "I think that a very good argument can be made for having an international force to restore peace."

This is a welcome development. And if the Archbishop’s going to be consistent, then we can shortly expect him to revisit his opposition to the Iraq war, and perhaps even confer retrospective approval on the Bush administration.

Tutu was an outspoken opponent of the invasion. Like many others he was critical of the flawed intelligence that was used to justify the war. However, he also contemptuously dismissed the secondary justification for the invasion – regime change.

This is what he said in a speech in London in February 2004.
‘But if now the reason being trumpeted for the war is regime change, why there and not for example, Burma? Or North Korea? And who makes the decision about which regimes should be changed? And what authority do they have to do whatever they think, may think is right? Or is it a matter of might is right, and to hell with the rule of international law?’
Leaving aside the silly and disingenuous argument that ‘if we can’t intervene everywhere we shouldn’t intervene anywhere’, and that the coalition had a sound legal basis on which to take action against Iraq, Apparently Tutu has apparently now conferred on himself the authority to decide which regimes should be changed.

Doubtless the Archbishop would protest that Zimbabwe is a different situation from Iraq. He might claim that his international force won’t be going in to effect regime change, but simply to restore order and safeguard the distribution of aid. Any intervention would, of course, spell the end of Mugabe’s rule.

Some might howl at this blatant double standard, accusing the Archbishop of deciding that intervention is okay, just as long as it's not America doing the intervening. And they might point out that if past experience with African 'peace-keeping' forces is anything to go by, the women and children of Zimbabwe are likely to be in as much danger from their liberators as they are from Mugabe's gangs.

But I prefer to celebrate the news that Archbishop Tutu has finally accepted the reality that sometimes, regrettably, it’s necessary to take military action against bad people in order to save innocent lives and establish democracy, up to and including killing anyone who gets in the way (His Grace hasn’t as yet gone into specifics as to the rules of engagement under which his ‘international force’ will operate, but I’m assuming that if they come under fire from Mugabe’s thugs, he’ll allow them to defend themselves).

This is quite an about-turn for the veteran human rights campaigner. In addition to opposing the Iraq war, Archbishop Tutu has been a vocal critic of Guantanamo and the military tribunals system. He’s also attacked Israel, going so far as to compare Israel’s occupation of Gaza and the West Bank with apartheid. However, he’s been such a powerful force for good in Africa, standing up to dictators of every political stripe, whether black or white, with equal forcefulness, that we can perhaps forgive him the occasional anti-American or anti-Israel outburst.

His Grace, like many soft-left types, appears to be motivated by a frustration with injustice, both real and imagined, and by the notion that if we just show kindness to evil people, then they’ll stop being evil. Despite the fact that they share a fondness for the Israel/apartheid analogy, I would certainly set him apart from bitter, hate-filled leftists like Jimmy Carter (who, lest we forget, played a key role in bringing Mugabe to power).

And anyway, it appears that His Grace’s anti-intervention days are now behind him. Many prominent neocons started out as lefties, and Archbishop Tutu appears to be the latest to see the light. Now I'm looking forward to his 'Why we can't let Iran get the bomb' speech.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

If you're wondering where all that aid money goes...

This is going to be bad news for Bono and Bob Geldof, but what a lot of people have long suspected is now official: every last penny in foreign aid sent to Africa is effectively being spent on waging war. The BBC reports:

A report on armed conflict in Africa has shown that the cost to the continent's development over a 15-year period was nearly $300bn (£146bn).

The research was undertaken by a number of non-governmental organisations, including Oxfam. It says the cost of conflict was equal to the amount of money received in aid during the same period.


The Guardian has more on the report, including this from Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, who wrote in an introduction to the report:

"The sums are appalling: the price that Africa is paying could cover the cost of solving the HIV and AIDS crisis in Africa, or provide education, water and prevention and treatment for tuberculosis and malaria.''

The report adds that, compared to peaceful countries, war-ravaged African nations have 50 per cent more infant deaths, 15 per cent more undernourished people, life expectancy reduced by five years and 12.4 per cent less food per person.

None of this will come as a surprise to those who argue that Africa is never going to be turned around as long as foreign governments, charities and organisations such as the UN and EU continue to treat it as one giant welfare junkie, pumping in billions of dollars in aid without making it conditional on political and social reform.

Africa needs our help, but it's time that well-meaning politicians and guilt-tripping celebrities stopped pretending that more money is the answer. We might as well cut out the middle-man and send over crates of AK-47s.

Other than emergency measures to alleviate chronic hunger and illness, aid should first and foremost take the form of real support for those working to advance democracy and peace, while European governments and the UN need to stop indulging tyrants like Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe, and instead arrest and charge them for war crimes and human rights abuses.

Sadly, despite the wake-up call this report should sound, nothing's likely to change in the near future. The current system benefits Africa's dictators and the corrupt bureaucracies of the EU and UN in equal measure.

Maybe someone could organise a series of rock concerts around the world to raise awareness of the problem. Another wristband, anyone?

Sunday, September 16, 2007

Church leader blasts Mugabe – is Brown listening?

Britain’s Archbishop of York has launched a scathing attack on Zimbabwean leader Robert Mugabe, calling him "the worst kind of racist dictator".

Dr John Sentam – who it should be pointed out is black – says Britain needs to escape its "colonial guilt" to tackle the Mugabe regime. And he says Gordon Brown must abandon the foreign policy towards Zimbabwe pursued by Tony Blair, with its emphasis on the role of neighbouring governments such as South Africa, and lead an international response.

The archbishop writes: "Having targeted the whites for their apparent riches, Mugabe has enacted an awful Orwellian vision, with the once oppressed taking on the role of the oppressor and glorying in their totalitarian abilities."

He also has strong words for South African president Thabo Mbeki, saying: "At worst, Mbeki is complicit in his failing to lead the charge against a neighbour who is systematically raping the country he leads."

The archbishop's outburst will be an embarrassment to the Brown government, which almost weekly makes some ambitious pledge or another about its plans for eradicating poverty in Africa, and ending conflicts there.

I made some similar points to the archbishop's a couple of weeks ago in this post.

Darfur: This time Brown means business. Again.

The platitudes are flying in a BBC interview with Gordon Brown over the situation in Darfur. Calling the conflict "one of the great tragedies of our time", Brown calls for the planned UN/African Union peacekeeping force to be in place by the end of the year, which it's supposed to be anyway, and warns of "further sanctions" against Sudan if attacks on refugees continue.

Considering that the 'international community' – led by those staunch internationalists China and Russia – has consistently refused to impose meaningful sanctions on Sudan, and that the peacekeepers' mandate basically limits them to running the UN flag up the pole every morning, President Omar al-Bashir and his coterie of thugs are unlikely to be quaking in their boots.

This is the most important intervention by Brown since his joint statement with Sarkozy last month calling for "intense action" to secure a ceasefire", which came hot on the heels of some tough talk at the UN in July

But help is on the horizon! The BBC reports that today has been declared a Global Day for Darfur (you didn't know?) with events planned in 30 nations around the world…

Campaigners from groups including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the Save Darfur Coalition plan to wear blindfolds in an appeal to world leaders not to look away from the continuing violence in Darfur.

Maybe if Amnesty and HRW expended a bit less energy on attacking America for slapping around the occasional mass-murdering jihadi, and Israel for having the temerity to defend its very existence, they might be able to move Darfur a little further up the agenda.

In the meantime I don't understand why President Bush doesn't take advantage of a glaring PR opportunity, and send a single B1 to vaporise the entire Sudanese air force in two minutes. Bashir would be at the negotiating table before the fires were out, and Bush would be able to tell the world: this is how to get things done.

I know that there are various international legal niceties that are supposed to be observed, and that the above groups would probably cry merry hell because said bomber was American, and not, say, Belgian, but what's the worst that could happen? Sanctions?

Saturday, September 8, 2007

The slow death of Zimbabwe

It looks increasingly as if Robert Mugabe will become the first leader in history to utterly destroy his country. Tyrants like Hitler led their countries to catastrophic defeats, but the damage was inflicted by their enemies. Zimbabwe’s woes are entirely the fault of Mugabe and his cronies.

In a harrowing report from the country, the BBC’s Sue Lloyd-Roberts tells of malnourished babies dying in hospitals, policemen looting food supplies and refugees fleeing over the border into South Africa only to be robbed, raped and killed.

There’s no precedent for what’s happening in Zimbabwe today, and no telling how the end will come for a country that just a few years ago was one of the most prosperous in Africa. A mass uprising or coup seems unlikely – most people seem to have lost the will to resist, and Mugabe’s soldiers and police are among the few who are getting enough to eat.

There appears to be little prospect for things improving as long as Mugabe is alive. Lloyd-Roberts concludes:

Thanks to the ingenuity and tolerance of people still in the country and the remittances sent back by those who have left, Zimbabwe's death throes could last a long time yet.

Other African states show no interest in intervening, with their leaders happy to give Mugabe a pass out of respect for his status as a revolutionary hero. And the international community doesn’t want to know either, not least because it helped Mugabe into power. It’s instructive at this time to recall the role that Jimmy Carter’s administration played in this respect, and how Carter’s people worked to undermine Zimbabwe-Rhodesia's moderate black leaders.

For Western nations to threaten action against Mugabe and his band of crooks and thugs would also be to imply that our values were in some way superior to theirs, and no-one at the UN or the EU would be caught dead suggesting such as thing. When Western nations interfere in Africa, even with the best of intentions, it’s called imperialism; when Africans destroy their own country, it’s called self-determination.

Sunday, August 5, 2007

Now THIS is an assault on civil liberties

If Nancy Pelosi and the Democrats are so concerned about the threat that government wiretapping poses to civil liberties, no doubt we can expect them to condemn Robert Mugabe's latest move to curtail said liberties in Zimbabwe.

Or perhaps not, given the Democrats' fondness for dictators other than the one they imagine occupies the White House, and the key role that the granddaddy of the American loony left, Jimmy Carter, played in bringing Mugabe to power – this superb piece by the Weekly Standard's James Kirchick is a fascinating account of a little-reported episode that's particularly shameful, even by the standards of the Carter years.

Thursday, August 2, 2007

UN acts on Darfur – don't hold your breath

After four years, at least 200,000 deaths and the displacement of some two million people, the UN has finally reached agreement on deploying peacekeepers to the Darfur region of Sudan. Unfortunately, the beleaguered people of Darfur aren't likely to notice much difference.

Concessions wrought by China and Russia, both of whom have lucrative oil and other trade deals with the murderous and corrupt Sudanese government, have rendered the mission's mandate so toothless as to be virtually irrelevant. Peacekeepers won't be allowed to disarm militias such as the government-supported Janjaweed, or arrest suspected war criminals. And, contrary to assertations by UK prime minister and UN cheerleader Gordon Brown a couple of days ago, Sudan will not face sanctions if it doesn't cooperate with the mission.

So Khartoum will continue to run rings around the 'international community' for a few months more (the peacekeepers won't even start arriving until October) while the UN and its friends hail another victory for diplomacy.

The BBC reports Jonathan Pearce, from the UK's Disasters Emergency Committee, as saying the peacekeeping force could make a "tremendous impact". If the unfortunate past history of UN peacekeeping in Sudan, and Africa in general is anything to go by, this tremendous impact is likely to be on statistics for rape, child abuse, gun-running and other criminality.

As an editorial in the Wall Street Journal puts it (subscription required): 'Khartoum won't tolerate a potent force in the absence of outside pressure – and China and Russia won't permit the U.N. to apply that pressure. Liberal moralists calling on the world to "do something" in Sudan while also putting faith in the U.N. above all else need to face up to this contradiction. Otherwise, there will be more Rwandas, Bosnias and Darfurs.'

The bureaucrats working for the most ineffective, wasteful and unaccountable institution in the history of the world will no doubt be celebrating their latest achievement by hammering their expense accounts in the finest hotels and restaurants that Africa, Europe and New York have to offer. In Darfur, people will continue to go hungry, flee their homes and die.